Walk-ins welcome, Monday to Saturday. No appointment needed.Get a price
The Tire Place USA Tire & Auto Repair
Advice · 5 min read

Nail in Your Tire? What to Do Next

The Tire Place USA shop in Deerfield Beach
The Tire Place USA Team Deerfield Beach since 2015 · FL registration MV114586 · Updated 13 November 2026
A nail stuck in the tread of a car tire

If the nail is in the tread and the tire is still holding air, leave the nail in and drive gently to a tire shop today. Don't pull it out. A hole up to 1/4 inch in the tread can usually be repaired, but a nail in the sidewall or shoulder means a new tire.

We've been pulling nails out of Deerfield Beach tires since 2015, and the quick plug is the thing our reviewers bring up again and again. Here's what to do, in the order you'll need it, starting from the moment you spot that shiny little head grinning up at you.

On this page

Can you drive with a nail in your tire?

Usually yes, for a short trip straight to a tire shop, as long as the tire is holding air and the nail is in the tread. The nail is working as a cork. It's plugging the hole it made, which is the most considerate thing a nail has ever done, and the second you yank it out, the air leaves with it.

Check the pressure with a gauge, or watch the low-tire light. Dropping fast? Don't drive on it.
Leave the nail exactly where it is. Today it's on your side.
Drive gently, skip I-95 if you can, and come straight in. This isn't the day for the scenic route.
Flat, or close to it? Put the spare on. Driving on a flat chews up the tire from the inside, and it can take the wheel down with it.
Leave the nail in. Right now it's the only thing in this situation doing its job.
A screw stuck near the edge of a car tire tread
A car tire sitting flat against the road

Left: a screw near the edge of the tread. That close to the shoulder, it needs a proper look before anyone promises a repair. Right: a tire that's given up, so the spare goes on and the driving stops.

Plug or patch: can a nail in a tire be fixed?

Most nails in the tread can be fixed. The US Tire Manufacturers Association says a repair is only OK if the hole is in the tread area and no bigger than 1/4 inch (USTMA, tire repair basics). Your tire doesn't care how small and innocent the nail looked going in. Location is everything, like real estate, but rounder.

There are two ways to fix it. A plug fills the hole from the outside, and it's quick and cheap. For a permanent repair, USTMA and AAA both say the hole gets filled and the inside of the tire gets a patch, and that a plug on its own is a temporary fix. We go deeper on that in how long a tire plug lasts.

A nail in the tread is a repair. A nail in the sidewall is a shopping trip.

How much does it cost to fix a nail in a tire?

At our shop, a plug or a patch is the whole bill for most nails. Walk in and we'll tell you which one your tire needs, priced before any work starts. More on our tire repair service. If the tire can't be saved, you're buying a new one, which is exactly where driving on a flat stops being free. What other shops charge is in what it costs to patch a tire.

A tire torn apart from being driven on while flat

Plug, patch or new tire: what fits

The short version.

Fix Time at our shop Best for
Plug About 20 minutes A small nail or screw in the tread
Patch About an hour Sealed from inside, wheel rebalanced
New tire Usually next day Sidewall, shoulder or big holes
Do nothing None Until it goes flat

What if the nail is in the sidewall?

Then it can't be repaired, and a shop that offers to plug it isn't doing you a favor. The sidewall and shoulder flex with every turn of the wheel, so AAA says a repair there won't hold. We'll show you exactly where the nail is and get you a new tire, usually by the next day. More in nail in tire sidewall.

Damage on the side of a car tire

Can you plug a run-flat tire?

Sometimes. Run-flats let you keep driving after a puncture, which is great right up until you wonder what that did to the inside of the tire. Each maker sets its own rule: Michelin says its run-flats can be repaired once, and other brands are stricter. Bring it in and we'll read your tire's markings with you, or see can you plug a run-flat tire.

What we see at the counter

Most plugs take about 20 minutes, and a patch about an hour. Bring a coffee for the patch.
Drivers sent away elsewhere with "come back tomorrow". We're open until 6pm on weekdays.
Tires other shops wanted to replace. One driver was told they needed two new tires, and we patched theirs.
When a plug is all your tire needs, we say so, and we don't sell you a tire you don't need.
they took my keys and in less an 20 minutes from arrival they had fixed my tire and got me on the road before 6pm. (Yelp review, January 2026)

When to stop driving and get it fixed

Today, if you can. A nail that's holding air this morning can work loose on the next pothole, and a slow leak has a talent for turning fast at the worst possible moment. Walk in Monday to Saturday, no appointment, and see tire repair.

Nail in tire questions

Can I drive on a tire with a nail in it?
For a short, gentle trip straight to a tire shop, if the tire is holding air and the nail is in the tread. If it's losing air fast or it's flat, put the spare on instead.

Should I pull the nail out?
No. The nail is sealing the hole it made. Leave it in until the tire is off the car and ready to be repaired.

Can a nail in the sidewall be fixed?
No. Damage in the sidewall or shoulder can't be repaired safely, so the tire needs replacing.

When is a nail in a tire unrepairable?
When the hole is bigger than 1/4 inch, when it's in the sidewall or shoulder, when it overlaps an old repair, or when the tire was driven flat and damaged inside.

How much does it cost to fix a nail in a tire?
It depends on whether it gets a plug or a patch. Walk in and we'll tell you which, with the price before any work starts.

Why do I keep getting nails in my tires?
Nails and screws collect near construction sites and along road shoulders, so a regular route past building work picks up more of them.

How long it takes A plug, about 20 minutes. A patch, about an hour.
What it costs Plug or patch, priced before we start. A new tire depends on the size.
When to come in It's losing air, the nail is near the sidewall, or you're not sure.
Nail in your tire right now? Walk in Monday to Saturday, no appointment. If it can't be fixed, we'll tell you why.
The Tire Place USA storefront
About the author

The Tire Place USA Team writes these guides from the counter of our walk-in tire and auto repair shop at 158 NW 1st St, Deerfield Beach, open since October 2015. Every outside fact links to its source.